
It should come as no surprise to most of the people who read this blog (all two of you) that I'm an atheist.
I believe that naturalistic accounts explain the universe better than theological ones. I believe that most of the arguments put forward for the existence of Gods (and the supernatural in general) are flawed and unconvincing. And I believe that a belief should stand or fall on the amount of cogent evidence that supports it. Assertion and intuition rarely convince anyone.
However, I'm not sure that the attempts to create organisations around atheism are that desirable. The term simply denotes a lack of theistic beliefs – within that category you get naturalism, scientism, humanism, agnosticism, objectivism, nihilism, etc. all of which look at the universe in quite different ways.
Stand me next to another atheist and – beyond the absence of religious beliefs – there's no guarantee that we'll have any values or outlooks in common. In fact, I find some atheists misguided, even repugnant in some of their views.
Just as I believe that religious moderates need to organise against the extremists in their midsts, non-theists need to promote the values at the heart of their worldview – my agnosticism, humanism, naturalism and rationalism define who I am far more than my views on the supernatural. Indeed, there are even theists who are closer to my views than some atheists. Which is why I don't display the attempts at an atheist symbol (no matter how snazzy they might look). Atheism isn't a value – it's an absence. Rather than defining ourselves by what we're against, we need to define ourselves by what we're for.
Thursday, November 01, 2007
Atheists of the world...
Posted by
Matt M
at
14:45
Labels: Politics, Religion, Secularism
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
7 comments:
Matt,
( - - - - - - - - - - - - - )
That's a picture of my silence, which indicates complete agreement.
#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#*#
That's a picture of my applause, which indicates my joy in seeing a little bit of passion in you. :)
*clap clap clap clap*
As you know I'm not an atheist but I don't see anything in your post to disagree with.
And stand me next to another theist and I'll possibly find nothing at all in common with them, especially if they hate Doctor Who. That doesn't mean that, a la John Mackie, I'd accuse them all of lying, just that, as you say, a shared theistic belief means nothing if someone is unable to appreciate adventures in time and space.
Plenty of agreement here as well. The only value in that rough territory that you might organise around is a desire to constrain the influence of religion on public life. But that's secularism, of course, and you don't have to be an atheist to support that.
So I'll not be displaying that symbol on my blog either - partly also because...
[off-topic rant]
Websense, which my work uses, has decided to start blocking Blogspot on the grounds of "emerging exploits". So no blogging for me. Grr.
[/off-topic rant]
TD,
a shared theistic belief means nothing if someone is unable to appreciate adventures in time and space.
I only have three words for anti-Whovians:
"Exterminate! Annihilate! Destroy!"
Tom,
Sorry to hear you've been locked out. If you want to keep on blogging, here's what you do:
1) Grab a cheap domain name and move your blog there. (Dead easy to do).
2) Enable blogging by email in your settings.
Freemania.net (or whatever you choose) will slip by any web guards and all you need to post is access to email.
Perfect.
Cheers for the advice Matt - I probably ought to do that. It'd get me a better URL.
But I've worked out a way round: I can go in via my dashboard in Blogger - which isn't blocked. Muppets.
So they've blocked any url with "blogspot" in it? Bummer.
Oh shit. We have a symbol now?
Jings, it looks like something you'd see on the chest of a man who wears his underpants over his tights.
People organising in the name of a common disbelief.
How perfectly ridiculous.
The only legitimate way to combat this heinous development is to rally together and show our opposition to being labelled.
My wife's a graphic designer; I'll have her whip up a pithy little sigil right now.
You're either with us, or against us.
Post a Comment